Join : Renew                       Home : Site Tools : Site map : Search
-

PSA - HomeEducating and Connecting People through Photography


 

More...
Increase font size Decrease font size Reset font size
set font size

Implementation Team (IT): Updates

August 27, 2012 - Last Communication from Implementation Team


STAR RATINGS CONVERSION
In our last IT Bulletin we noted a number of member questions about the status of Star Ratings and acceptances accumulated in the Color Projected Image Division (CPID) and/or the Electronic Imaging Division (EID) sections of PSA-recognized international exhibitions.

Q. What happens to any acceptances I earn in either CPID or EID recognized exhibitions that are judged after September 22, 2012? Will I lose any acceptance I might receive once those divisions cease operation at the end of the 2012 PSA Conference?

A. Any eligible acceptance earned in a CPID or EID recognized exhibition, no matter the closing date, will count towards CPID or EID Star Ratings. That includes any CPID or EID exhibition with a 2013 closing date.

Q. I have received acceptances for the same image with the same title in both CPID and EID recognized exhibitions. What happens to those duplicate title images on conversion?

A. CPID acceptances and EID acceptances of the same image will be considered different titles. Additional acceptances of the same title in PID recognized exhibitions will not count as a new title but if working on Stars 1-5 will still count as additional acceptances of titles already being used. If working on Galaxy levels, additional acceptances in PID recognized sections of the same titles will not be considered different titles but can be apportioned between the CPID and EID acceptances to make the full set of three acceptances per title.

For example, if an exhibitor has three acceptances of a title in CPID and one or more in EID, additional acceptances of the same title in PID recognized exhibitions can be used to complete the EID number of acceptances for that title.

And, if an exhibitor had two acceptances in CPID and two acceptances in EID, two additional acceptances in PID would be apportioned to each for a total of two titles accepted three times.

If the combination of CPID stars and EID stars pushed a member working on Stars 1 - 5 in either Division into the Galaxy level for PID, any acceptance that would have been eligible towards the 4th or 5th star in either CPID or EID will still be eligible for the Galaxy in PID. If the eligible acceptances not already been used for the previous CPID or EID star ratings exceed the three acceptances of a title required for the galaxy, the number of acceptances of that title in that Division will be divided by three and given credit as different titles. If, prior to the start-up of PID, a member was already at the Galaxy level for either Division, then such excess acceptances would be lost within that Division anyway.  This is explained in the next question as well.
 
Q.           How will the Star conversion option be handled by PID?

A.            The conversion process is not being combined with applications for any other ratings.  It is only being applied to Stars received.  You will be required to include copies of your latest approved EID Star Ratings and CPID Star Ratings applications when applying for your next PID rating.

The conversion of CPID and EID Star Ratings to PID Star Ratings itself will not cause loss of any Star Rating since the conversion is based on the Stars members have already achieved and will not be combined with applications for new stars within that division.

However, members should not hold off converting to the new unified Star Rating system any old CPID Stars or EID stars that are not based on the current uniform Star Ratings program as that will simplify the PID conversion process. Those conversions are separate and will not be combined with conversions to PID stars.

When a member applies for their first star under PID they send in the same paperwork as for the past Star Rating in each Division just as they would if applying for a new Star in those Divisions.  In addition they’ll need to send in a transmittal letter for their converted PID rating.

All CPID and EID acceptances that are eligible for the CPID and/or EID star level the member is working on prior to the creation of the PID Division will be eligible for stars under the PID Star Rating System. If the combination of CPID stars and EID stars pushes the member to the Galaxy Level, each three acceptances of the same title will be considered a separate title for a PID Galaxy Ratings application with no regards to whether the titles were validated for star ratings below the Galaxy level.

The PID Star Ratings procedures will also consider the same image accepted in CPID and EID as different titles.  Additional acceptances of the same title in PID recognized exhibitions will not count as a new title but, if working on Stars 1-5, will still count as additional acceptances of titles already being used. If working on Galaxy levels, additional acceptances in PID recognized sections of the same titles will not be considered different titles but can be apportioned between the CPID and EID acceptances to make the full set of three acceptances per title.

For example: If an exhibitor had three acceptances of a title in CPID and one or more in EID, additional acceptances of the same title in PID recognized exhibitions can be used to complete the EID number of acceptances.

Another example: With two acceptances in CPID and two acceptances in EID, two additional acceptances in PID would be apportioned to each for a total of two titles accepted three times.
 
Although we’ve tried to outline the CPID/EID Star conversion to PID Star Ratings as clearly as possible in a limited space, we recognize that each member’s situation will be unique to their individual Star Ratings profile. The important point for members to keep in mind is acceptances earned in any EID and CPID recognized exhibition, regardless of their closing date, will continue to accrue towards separate Star Ratings in each of those Divisions.

In the interim, if you have any Star Ratings questions, please contact Dan Charbonnet, FPSA, EPSA, Exhibition Services Vice President [ddrc3@msn.com].
 
Final Implementation Team Bulletin
In April, 2012 the PSA Board established an Implementation Team to set up PSA’s new Projected Image Division (PID). Over the past 4 months the IT members have determined the new division name, provided a recommended list of PID officer candidates and appointed Directors for 14 PID programs. Over 21 PSA members, from a number of Divisions and others new to PSA, have responded favorably to the call to be a member of the PID team. These volunteers bring a wealth of experience and enthusiasm to each of their roles. We look forward in confidence that PID will quickly find its place along-side the other PSA divisions and provide a valued service to PSA.
 
We will soon see the official start-up of PID at the close of the 2012 PSA Conference in San Francisco. The Implementation Team has completed its primary role, and it is now time to transition responsibilities to PID Officers and Directors.
 
As this will be the Implementation Teams’ last bulletin to PSA members, I want to sincerely thank the members of the team: Sam Shaw, Diane Racey, Wally Lee, Larry Cowles, Dennis Hirning, Tony Potter, Dana Vannoy (ex officio) and Dan Charbonnet (ex officio). We have had a busy and intense summer setting up programs and assigning roles to volunteers so that PID can be fully operational this autumn. The Projected Image Division will be ready, following the 2012 Conference, to provide all PSA members with the services they have come to expect from any PSA division. We could not have achieved so much in such a short time without the expertise and enthusiasm of the committed members of the Implementation Team.
 
Terry Carroll, APSA
Chairman, Implementation Team
Email: twcarroll@accesscable.net
 
Effective immediately by Executive Order, the Implementation Team is dissolved with the thanks and appreciation of the Society for a job well done.


 

July 24, 2012 - Communication Bulletin From Implementation Team

The Implementation Team has been assigned the task to set up PSA’s new Division, the Projected Image Division (PID). Included is appointment of Directors of programs and services enjoyed by members of other Divisions.

Program Director Appointments

We’re pleased to report that we have attracted experienced volunteers as PID Officers and Directors of programs and services. These members have willingly agreed to serve and will bring their skills and enthusiasm to PID’s team. We look forward to providing great programs to members in a similar manner as those offered by other PSA Divisions.

Chairman - Dennis Hirning, EPSA
1st Vice Chairman - Larry Durbin, APSA, PPSA
 2nd Vice Chairman - Kate Webb, EPSA
Secretary - Signe Emmerich
Treasurer - Eric Rosengren, APSA, PPSA
Study Groups - Barbara Miller, FPSA, PPSA, and Les Milligan, FPSA
Photo Essay Competition - Nancy Sams, FPSA, EPSA
Individual Portrait Competition - Steve Stavri
Individual Creative Competition - Tom Peterson
Image of the Year - Sue Milligan
TOPS - Norbert Heil
Interclub Competition - Bob Benson
Interclub Creative Competition - Tom Peterson
Exhibition Standards Directors - Larry Cowles, FPSA, GMPSA, and Graeme Webb
Star Ratings Director - Wally Lee, APSA, PPSA
PSA Journal News Editor - Carol Kropscot, APSA
Service Awards - Sandra Matson
Historian - Sandra Matson

Exhibitions

One of the key PID programs will be exhibition recognition. As we expect that the volume of exhibition recognition applications will be considerable, we have appointed two Exhibition Standards Directors. Larry and Graeme are two very experienced exhibitors and will bring a wealth of knowledge their role as ESD’s. In addition, we will also be appointing a medal coordinator tasked with distribution of exhibition medals to exhibition sponsors.

Star Ratings Conversion

One of the most frequent member questions is the status of Star Ratings and acceptances accumulated in Color Projected Image Division (CPID) and/or Electronic Image Division (EID). What about 2012 exhibitions already recognized by CPID and EID, will I lose any acceptances once those divisions cease operation at the end of the 2012 PSA Conference? How will the Star conversion option be handled by PID?

While we’re not in a position to respond to those questions at this time, we can advise that we have a committee developing recommendations on how to best convert acceptances where members are both CPID and EID exhibitors.  We recognize that each member’s situation will be unique to their individual Star Ratings profile.

The important point for members to keep in mind is acceptances earned in any EID and/or CPID recognized exhibition will continue to accrue towards separate Star Ratings in each of those Divisions or, if the member chooses, those acceptances may be applied towards PID Star Ratings. All CPID or EID acceptances, that would have been valid before conversions, will still be counted. Any acceptance earned in CPID or EID recognized exhibitions that comply with the respective Division's Star program is valid will not be lost.

Conversion of CPID and EID Star Ratings to PID Star Ratings will not commence until the conclusion of the CPID and EID recognized exhibitions in early 2013.

We are working on a separate communication that we expect will be issued within the next couple weeks dealing strictly with the conversion of PSA members CPID and EID Star Ratings and acceptances.

2012 EID Star Ratings and Who's Who

We regret to report that Nick Muskovac, FPSA, MPSA, has resigned as EID Star Ratings and Who’s Who Director. Nick was a founding member of EID and from day one has been one of the principle contributors to the success of that Division. We sincerely thank Nick for his outstanding service to PSA.

To provide continuity of EID Star ratings and Who’s Who programs for 2012, we’re pleased to have Wally Lee, APSA, PPSA, agree to assume EID Star Ratings responsibilities effective immediately. In addition Wes Kirkpatrick has agreed to complete the compilation of Who’s Who standing for 2012. With that appointment of Wally and Wes members should not see any interruption of service to these important programs.

ROPA Applications

Members have wondered on whether it is better to apply for ROPA DISTINCTIONS now or wait until the new Division is active. My recommendation is to apply now if you have stars in both CPID and EID. Once the new Division is active, the converted stars will be just as valid for the ROPA levels but if you have stars in both CPID and EID the acceptance counts associated with the converted stars may initially be lower than the combined acceptance counts of the two current divisions. The counts will catch up with the first PID star level you apply for after conversion but why wait?

PID Home Page

We are in the process of setting up PID’s home page on the PSA web site. Once it is operational, PSA individual and club members will have a complete source of information about PID and it programs.

Terry Carroll, APSA
Chairman, Implementation Team
Email: twcarroll@accesscable.net

June 4, 2012 -  Communication Bulletin From IT Chairman, Terry Carroll, APSA

NEW PSA DIVISION is the PROJECTED IMAGE DIVISION

The Implementation Team (IT) reviewed a number of suggested names for PSA's newest division. The team was guided in its recommendation by both the history of other division names and the need to provide clarity so that members would recognize the new division's focus within its name. After careful consideration of several options, the IT recommended and the PSA Board unanimously approved that the new PSA division would be called "PROJECTED IMAGE DIVISION (PID)".

Some IT members and PSA Board members made the following comments about the new name: "It provides the least confusion and the most flexibility for the new Division;" "It is appropriate that it does not place limits on the subject matter of the division;" and "It says what it is but is short and to the point."

PROJECTED IMAGE OFFICERS
The Implementation Team suggested a roster of possible officers for the new division and forwarded those to John Davis, PSA President who then appointed the officers. The President is very pleased to announce the following appointments for the first term of the Projected Image Division:

Chairman Dennis Hirning, EPSA
1st Vice Chairman Larry Durbin, APSA, PPSA
2nd Vice Chairman Kate Webb, EPSA
Secretary Signe Emmerich
Treasurer Erik Rosengren, APSA, PPSA

The IT is pleased to have such dedicated and experienced PSA members agreeing to serve as Officers for this newest Division. The Implementation Team is aware that the slate it proposed to the Board of Directors had 3 members who have been serving in the same positions in the two divisions being dissolved. However, the team firmly believed that it was extremely important to start the new division with officers who have experience and timely knowledge of both CPID and EID operations. Organizing a new division will bring on a number of challenges. Its early success will be realized because of the dedication and determination these new officers bring to their positions.

During the course of its deliberations, the PSA Board of Directors also realized the situation and discussed it fully. In the end, the Board voted unanimously to approve the Implementation Team's recommendations. Subsequently, the new PID officers were installed by Presidential Appointment.
As with any start-up, everyone will need to be patient as we work through all the issues in setting up this new Division. The IT will also need everyone's help in ensuring that we have the appropriate programs and services to best serve the interests of members. Thank you and congratulations to these new officers!

Study Groups
One of the first activities the IT group examined was CPID and EID Study Groups. It is widely recognized that all the groups are highly valued by those who participate. In fact the recent member survey conducted by the EID/CPID Study Task Force showed that of the many programs offered by both divisions, the Study Groups were of high importance. Memberswanted them to continue as presently structured and not be changed.

The IT agreed that the best solution would be to make no changes in Study Groups other than that they would now be hosted in one division instead of two. We are pleased to confirm that Study Group Directors Barbara Miller, FPSA, PPSA and Les Milligan, FPSA, have agreed to continue as Co-Directors for the Study Group Program in the Projected Image Division. Each already supervises a number of study groups, and they will continue to direct the groups they now monitor with their respective group administers. This will provide the least amount of disruption to the PSA members within these Study Groups. The Team understands that the CPID and EID current Study Groups operate differently. Members of the EID Study Groups strongly recommended that how their program operates not be changed. CPID Study Group members would also like to keep their program operating as it is presently. The IT agrees to maintain both program delivery methods. The primary difference is one division currently employs password protection distinct to each group whereas the other division does not have restricted access. There is value in both formats. We believe that if we transition both methods under continuing leadership, then members will continue to participate and enjoy uninterrupted what hasbecome a valued component of their PSA membership.

We're pleased that Barbara and Les have agreed to provide their expertise and dedication by continuing to manage this important program for PSA members.

ROPA APPLICATIONS
While the IT will plan the merger and conversion process for CPID and EID Star Ratings, some have asked about the impact of the cessation of CPID and EID on ROPA applications. ROPA applications may be submitted at any time, supported by CPID and/or EID Star Ratings certificates. At some point, the old EID and CPID Star certificates may need to be converted to PID certificates if and when a member wishes to gain higher Star or Galaxy Ratings. While we are currently working on the conversion process, that should have no impact on any current or pending ROPA application. In sum, old CPID and EID certificates may be used for ROPA; there is no need to convert these certificates first.

DATE CORRECTION (EXHIBITIONS)
In our first E-News Bulletin, we stated that "all requests for hosting an exhibition will continue without change; EID and CPID applications will remain separate until January 1, 2012." The 2012 date was in error and is 2013. The correct date for beginning PID exhibitions will be January 1, 2013.

The IT will provide regular communication to members as the team continues the process of initiating the new Division. In the interim, if you have any question or concerns, please forward your thoughts as they will help ensure that the Implementation Team is aware of all the issues that need to be addressed.

Terry Carroll, APSA
Chairman, Implementation Team
Email: twcarroll@accesscable.net


 May 15, 2012 - Communication Bulletin From IT Chairman, Terry Carroll

The Implementation Team (IT) appointment is now complete with the following members: Members-At-Large Sam Shaw and Diane Racey; Wally Lee and Larry Cowles representing CPID; Dennis Hirning and Tony Potter representing EID; and me as Chairman. In addition Dana Vannoy, Divisions Vice President, and Dan Charbonnet, Exhibition Services Vice President, act as ex-officio, non-voting members of the team. We're honored that these PSA members have agreed to work on the important task of establishing a new Division that can encompass the best programs and services currently offered by CPID and EID.

Our task is to recommend a name and executive team for the new PSA Division. In addition we are to review all current CPID and EID programs and determine how they might be integrated in a new Division with the least disruption of service while also looking at how the programs might be improved by building from the success of the current programs hosted by CPID and EID.

Both EID and CPID programs and activities will remain active with no change until the end of the PSA Conference in San Francisco. In particular all Study Groups and exhibition programs, including exhibition recognition services, Star Ratings and Who's Who, will operate without change while the IT reviews how the new division might continue those programs without interruption of service to our members.

We have already received a number of member concerns about study groups and exhibition acceptances. While we have not reviewed all aspects of those programs we can outline our plans.

We would expect the current EID and CPID Study Groups to continue as presently structured. We would hope that the only change would be the assignment of the Groups to the new Division with the current Study Groups membership remaining as at present. We understand that currently EID and CPID Study Groups operate differently. The IT group will look at options for this service and, if deemed appropriate, will adopt the best means to serve our Study Groups.

The second area of concern is exhibitions. First, all requests for hosting an exhibition will continue without change; EID and CPID applications will remain separate until January 1, 2013. The only exception will be exhibitions applying after September 22, 2012 to host both CPID and EID sections. Those exhibitions will need to determine which sections they are willing to host to avoid overlap or duplicate exhibition opportunities for PSA members.

Not unexpectedly, members have concerns about acceptances gained in EID, CPID or both Divisions. There will be a merger and conversion of those acceptances with the plan to make every effort to preserve members' acceptances. The plan will be to honor all acceptances not previously claimed at the time of the establishment of the new Division on conclusion of the PSA Conference in San Francisco. In the interim, if a member wishes to apply for an EID and/or a CPID Star Rating, there is no advantage in waiting for the setup of the new Division. Conversion application details will be determined over the next few months.

The IT group plans to provide regular communication to members as we embark on the process to initiate the new Division. In the interim, if you have any question or concerns, please forward your thoughts to me as they will help ensure our IT group is aware of all the issues they need to address.

Terry Carroll, APSA
Chairman, Implementation Team